Engraving of Victorian gamblers handing long chains of betting slips to a clerk beneath a glowing orange orb

👋 Hey, welcome to Predicted, the newsletter covering the business of prediction markets.

Forwarded this email and want it in your inbox? Hit the subscribe button below! 👇

Discussed in this piece:

  1. Parlays are two-thirds of US notional volume

  2. Where a parlay customer's money goes

  3. Why parlay customers lose

  4. Who the parlay customers are

  5. What parlays mean for a Kalshi IPO

  6. What we are watching

This piece was written and researched by Omar El Safy and edited by Pet Berisha.

Kalshi's parlay customers have lost $1 billion since the product launched in September 2025, InGame found, and almost half of that went in the eight weeks after the NFL season kicked off.

We have covered parlays four times this year, on whether they pay the bills, how big Kalshi's parlay market really is, how they compare across exchanges, and how buyers keep reaching for longer shots.

This one looks at the customers, why they lose and who they are, and why it matters now that Kalshi are in talks to raise at a $65 billion valuation.

Fig. 0. Kalshi parlay notional volume and handle by month, with losses to date. November 2026 runs to the 17th. Source: The Prediction, InGame.

If you haven't read our Q3 2026 report yet, you should. It’s the most comprehensive Prediction Market report ever.

Read it for free below! 👇

State of Prediction Markets - Q3 2026
State of Prediction Markets - Q3 2026
The most comprehensive report ever on prediction markets, Q3 2026.
$0.00 usd

01 - Parlays are two-thirds of US notional volume

A year ago, in October 2025, parlays were 1.8% of the notional volume on US-regulated exchanges.

By Q3 2026, they were 44%; in October 2026, 65%, and so far in November 2026, 68%.

That means 2 of every 3 dollars of notional volume on a US prediction market right now are on parlay-style contracts.

Fig. 1. US notional volume, parlays against everything else, updated to November 2026 from our Q3 2026 report. Circles mark when each exchange added parlays. Source: The Prediction.

The newer exchanges caught up fast. In October 2026, parlays were 58% of Polymarket US's notional volume two months after they added them, and 73% at DKeX, the exchange owned by DraftKings ($DKNG ( ▼ 6.06% )), which first traded in late August 2026. UDX was highest at 78%.

Parlays as a share of each venue's October 2026 notional volume

Fig. 2. Parlays' share of each exchange's notional volume, October 2026, updated from the Q3 2026 version in our Q3 2026 report. Source: The Prediction.

02 - Where a parlay customer's money goes

Say you put $5 on a five-leg parlay priced at 5¢, about 19/1 in traditional odds. Your $5 buys 100 contracts, each paying $1 if all five legs come in, so your ticket pays $100 if you win.

You are the taker, because you take the price you are offered. A market maker sets that 5¢ price through a request for quote (RFQ) and takes the bet against you. And Kalshi charge a fee of 34¢, about 6.8% of your $5, which they keep whether you win or lose.

The $100 you could win is what gets reported as notional volume, and the $5 you spent is the handle.

In October 2026, parlays accounted for $80.3B of notional volume on the six US exchanges that publish parlay handle, on just $3.45B of handle.

Fig. 3. Parlay notional volume against handle, updated to October 2026 from our Q3 2026 report. Kalshi's handle is estimated. Source: The Prediction.

InGame found that on Kalshi, when customers lose, the money goes two ways.

1) $608.9M went to market makers through the price of the bets.

2) $400M went to Kalshi in fees.

That is about 14¢ of every $1 of handle, where a sportsbook keeps up to 20% on parlays, and $141.8M of it came from customers cashing out early, InGame found.

03 - Why parlay customers lose

Two things eat into a parlay customer's handle.

1. The fee, on every ticket.

Kalshi charges its fee whether you win or lose, and it takes a bigger slice of a cheap ticket. On our $5 bet at 5¢, the fee is 34¢, or 6.8% of your money. The same $5 on a single bet priced at 50¢, a coin flip, would pay 18¢, or 3.6%. Parlays are almost all cheap long shots, so they pay the bigger slice.

The same $5 on two Kalshi tickets: a five-leg parlay at 5 cents pays a 34 cent fee, 6.8%; a single bet at 50 cents, a coin flip, pays 18 cents, 3.6%

Fig. 4. The same $5 on two Kalshi tickets. Kalshi's taker fee, rounded up to the cent. Source: Kalshi, The Prediction.

2. The price, on the longest shots.

We checked whether Kalshi's parlay prices are fair, using 3.56 million real Kalshi trades from 342 random minutes between 20 September 2026 and 15 November 2026, each matched to how its bet finished.

A fair price means that if you bet $100 on many tickets of the same kind, the winners pay back about $100.

Say a parlay costs 1¢ and pays $1, so its price says it wins about 1 time in 100. Spread $100 across 10,000 of them and about 100 should win, paying back $100.

On long-shot parlays, those priced under 2¢, the winners paid back about $85 for every $100 spent, before the fee. On less extreme parlays, $100 came back as roughly $100. That gap goes to the market makers.

Fig. 5. Money back per $1 of handle on Kalshi, by price paid, before fees. Sample of 3.56M trades, small bars are noise. Source: The Prediction.

Measured as money back against money spent before fees, parlays under 2¢ came back 14.9% short. In every other price range, parlays landed within about 3% of fair either way, close to break-even in a sample this size, and single bets also lost most at the lowest prices.

As we previously covered on Predicted, customers keep reaching for longer shots, and they still are. The average Kalshi parlay cost 8.9¢, about 10/1, in October 2025, and 4.0¢, about 24/1, in October 2026, by our estimate.

Average price of a Kalshi parlay by month, from 8.9 cents (about 10/1) in October 2025 to 4.0 cents (about 24/1) in October 2026

Fig. 6. Average price of a Kalshi parlay by month, handle divided by notional volume. Estimated, and slightly high against real trades. Source: The Prediction.

The bottom line is that a parlay customer now pays twice, through the fee on every ticket and through the price on the long shots, and both get worse the longer the ticket gets.

04 - Who the parlay customers are

In September 2026, 55% of Kalshi's card deposits came from the 11 states without legal sports betting, home to only 32% of US adults, according to American Spend's data in our Q3 2026 report.

Fig. 7. Share of card deposits from the 11 states without legal sports betting. From our Q3 2026 report. Source: American Spend.

And a large chunk of those deposits comes from young people. In Q3 2026, 18- to 24-year-olds made up 30% of Kalshi's card deposits and 39% of Polymarket US's, against 16% at DraftKings' sportsbook and about 10% of all US card spending.

Fig. 8. Share of card deposits by age, Q3 2026. Unknown ages left out. From our Q3 2026 report. Source: American Spend.

No exchange publishes losses by age, so we cannot say whether young customers lose more. Surveys do show how much young people use these apps, and whether they think of them as betting or investing.

An AIBM and Ipsos poll in March 2026 found 26% of men aged 18 to 24 had used a sports betting, fantasy or prediction market app in the past six months, against 14% of all adults. Most Americans in the poll still saw prediction markets as closer to gambling than investing, at 47% to 10%.

Young investors draw that line less clearly. In a Betterment survey of 1,000 US investors in March and April 2026, 52% of the Gen Z investors said they had moved money meant for investing into sports betting, and 26% treat betting as part of their long-term financial strategy.

Some regulators are asking the same question in law, whether these contracts are gambling that needs a state licence or financial products overseen by the federal regulator.

Louisiana, which does have legal sports betting, sued Kalshi, Polymarket, Robinhood ($HOOD ( ▼ 9.44% )), Coinbase ($COIN ( ▼ 6.34% )) and others on 12 November 2026, and a judge barred 31 companies from offering the contracts in the state the same day. "It's not complicated: if you aren't a licensed gaming operator, you aren't legal," attorney general Liz Murrill said.

Our read is that the next fight could be over age.

Kalshi accept customers from 18, while most states make sportsbook customers wait until 21, and rivals Novig and Fanatics Markets have chosen 21 themselves. Parlays are priced like long-shot bets; most of their buyers lose, and the apps selling them draw far more of their card deposits from people under 25 than sportsbooks do.

05 - What parlays mean for a Kalshi IPO

Kalshi CEO Tarek Mansour has confirmed IPO talks, though not for 2026, and Polymarket are weighing one too. We estimate about $225M of Kalshi's roughly $1.0B in Q3 2026 fees came from parlays.

Fig. 9. Exchange fees by category, Q3 2026. From our Q3 2026 report. Source: The Prediction estimates.

We estimate Kalshi earned about 5.3¢ in fees for every $1 of parlay handle in Q3 2026, more than twice the 2.4¢ on everything else. Parlays were 11% of Kalshi's handle and 22% of its fees.

But that money comes from customers who mostly lose. Kalshi's parlay customers are $1 billion down since launch, and $400M of that went to Kalshi in fees.

Sportsbooks make money the same way, and DraftKings are a listed company built on it. Kalshi and Polymarket sell themselves as exchanges, where customers trade with each other, and the exchange takes no side.

A prospectus would have to explain why their best-paying product works like a sportsbook, with the customer on one side, a market maker on the other and the customer losing consistently over time.

Investors would also ask whether those customers come back. No exchange publishes how many parlay customers keep trading after they lose, and finding new ones is expensive, with DraftKings expecting to spend $650 million to $700 million on Predictions in 2026.

Our read is that parlays give Kalshi and Polymarket fast-growing revenue on a product cheaper than a sportsbook's, but the same numbers make it hard to argue prediction markets are not just new venues for gambling.

06 - What we are watching

  1. If new exchanges add parlays and how much of their notional volume they become, after DKeX reached 73% within two months of launching and Polymarket US 58% within two months of adding them.

  2. Whether parlays spread from sports into politics and other categories, after Kalshi's parlays ran to $27.8B of notional volume in the ten days around the 2026 midterms, against $1.3B on the election markets themselves.

  3. Whether regulators and politicians turn on parlays because of who is buying them, with 30% of Kalshi's card deposits coming from 18- to 24-year-olds, and what that would do to the fee revenue Kalshi and Polymarket would take to public markets, where parlays made up about 22% of Kalshi's Q3 2026 fees.

———————————————————————————

Disclaimers

This newsletter is for informational purposes only and is not financial, business or legal advice. These are the author's thoughts & opinions and do not represent the opinions of any other person, business, entity or sponsor. Any companies, platforms, markets or projects mentioned are for illustrative purposes unless specified.

The contents of this newsletter should not be used in any public or private domain without the express permission of the author.

The contents of this newsletter should not be used for any commercial activity, for example - research report, consultancy activity, or paywalled article without the express permission of the author.

Please note, the services and products advertised by our sponsors (by use of terminology such as but not limited to; supported by, sponsored by or brought to you by) in this newsletter carry inherent risks and should not be regarded as completely safe or risk-free. Third-party entities provide these services and products, and we do not control, endorse, or guarantee the accuracy, efficacy, or safety of their offerings.

When you trade on prediction markets (including event contracts, opinion markets and other speculative instruments) your capital is at risk. Risks include price volatility, loss of capital, illiquidity, complexity, evolving regulation and lack of protection. Many prediction market operators do not currently operate in a fully regulated industry, and availability varies by jurisdiction. You may not be protected under financial compensation schemes typically afforded to investors dealing with regulated entities. Nothing in this newsletter constitutes a recommendation to place, hold, or close any position on any market.